How far will lawyers go?

"No injury should go uncompensated," or so many Americans believe today.
Someone must be held to blame; hence, someone should pay. Although it would be
nice to expect financial renumeration for injury, however incurred, it is simply
fiscally irresponsible and socially impossible to accomplish this goal.

In California, a burglar fell through a school skylight while attempting a 1:00 a.m. illegal entry. Dropping some 20 feet, he sustained some nasty injuries. He later retained an attorney and brought suit against the school and skylight manufacturer on the grounds that the skylight bore no warning that it was of insufficient weight-bearing strength.

The legal system affects product manufacturers, because they, and other deep-pocket defendants such as municipalities, have money and so are targeted. Lawyers rarely sue indigents.

How far will lawyers go to extract money from corporate defendants? In Texas, where judges are elected, often with the plaintiffs' bar's financial support, huge verdicts and sizable settlements are the rule in civil litigation. Duval County enjoys a reputation as a county particularly conducive to high plaintiffs' awards and so is popular with the plaintiffs' bar.

Legal wrangling in Texas. Survivors of a bloody 1991 shootout in a Taco Bell near Dallas sued the restaurant chain. According to the National Law Journal, the plaintiff's counsel was unsatisfied with the case's Dallas County venue, where the judicial climate is more reasonable. Yet, even in the liberal venue laws of Texas, which permits a suit to be brought in any county where a party resides, Dallas seemed the required litigation site. The millions of dollars at stake, however, proved a natural stimulus to the lawyer's ingenuity.

Colleague sued. The assailants who had gunned down the plaintiff were serving 40 to 50 years in the state penitentiary and were insolvent. So the plaintiffs' attorney, John Cracken, retained his own attorney to represent state prison inmate Jerome Green, one of the accomplices. His colleague was the actual shooter. Green sued his colleague--in Duval County.

Although Green had always lived hundreds of miles from Duval County, for some mystical reason he decided that when he's released from prison around the year 2030, that's where he will move, and he signed a statement expressing this intent. This permitted Cracken to sue Green in Duval County. Green's attorney, hired by and paid for by Cracken, did not dispute this shaky basis for jurisdiction in Duval and filed a two-paragraph answer. Hence, the Duval County Court accepted jurisdiction. The same day, Cracken gained venue in Duval County for his clients and sued Taco Bell in Duval, since Texas state law provides that once venue is found for one defendant, anyone else can be added as a defendant.

The moral? Tort litigation is a $100-billion-a-year business which may threaten a corporation's existence. The stakes are enormous. Local favoritism isn't limited to Texas. Understanding the vagaries of litigation and its financial risks should motivate companies to design and manufacture quality products, properly label and warn the consumer, and in the event of litigation, retain competent counsel to protect their legal interests.

Legal Questions

Q. How

Add new comment

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.